Skip to content
Go back

Impostor syndrome: why it hits competent people and how to get past it

Illustration of a confident person reflected in a mirror as a doubtful figure

There’s something odd about people who feel like impostors at work: they’re almost always good. It isn’t the unprepared person who fears being found out, because that one is usually quite relaxed. It’s the person who studied, who has documentable results, who does the job well, who wakes up convinced that sooner or later someone will notice.

Three claims about this topic circulate everywhere, and two of them are wrong. It’s worth starting there, because correcting them is already half the work.

This article is about a common experience, not a diagnosis. If the distress is persistent, affects your sleep, your mood or your ability to work, the right move is to talk to a mental health professional, not to read an article.

First correction: it isn’t a syndrome

The term comes from a 1978 paper by Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes, The Impostor Phenomenon in High Achieving Women. The authors deliberately called it a phenomenon, not a syndrome: they were describing a recurring pattern observed in more than 150 women with objectively high achievement who attributed their success to luck, timing, or an ability to appear more competent than they felt.

It has never been a clinical diagnosis. It doesn’t appear in the DSM-5 or in the World Health Organization’s ICD-11. Calling it a “syndrome” has two concrete, unhelpful effects: it makes something that often isn’t purely individual look like an individual defect, and it moves attention from the context to the person.

The same structure applies to burnout: there too the WHO classifies it as an occupational phenomenon rather than a medical condition. The parallel is discussed in burnout: recognising and preventing it.

Second correction: the 70% statistic is unreliable

“70% of people experience it at least once in their lives” is the most quoted sentence on the subject. It doesn’t come from an epidemiological study: it has circulated since a popular estimate in the 1980s and has been repeated until it became a fact.

Here’s what the research says instead. In 2020 Bravata and colleagues published a systematic review of the available studies in the Journal of General Internal Medicine. The most useful result isn’t a percentage but an observation: prevalence estimates vary enormously across studies, from single digits to over 80%, because the measurement instruments differ, the thresholds used to define “present” differ, and the populations examined differ (often medical students rather than workers in general).

The review also notes that studies on treatment are few and methodologically weak. Anyone promising a scientifically validated five-step method is overstating, and this article is no exception: what follows is reasonable and consistent with what’s known, not a demonstrated protocol.

Common claimActual status
”It’s a syndrome”Not a diagnosis: absent from DSM-5 and ICD-11
”It affects 70% of people”Estimates vary enormously by study and instrument
”It mostly affects women”First observed in women, but reported across all groups
”It hurts performance”Less obvious than it sounds: see below
”It goes away once results arrive”False: results are exactly when it intensifies

Third correction: it may not be purely a defect

Here’s the most counterintuitive finding. Basima Tewfik published a study in the Academy of Management Journal (2022) on “impostor thoughts” in workplace settings. People reporting them tend to display more other-oriented behaviour (more listening, more attention to the other party), and on some measures of interpersonal effectiveness this translated into better assessments, without the performance drop you’d expect.

Take it for what it is: one study, not a law, and certainly not an invitation to feel bad because it’s good for your career. But it’s enough to question the assumption that self-doubt is purely a defect to be eliminated.

The practical point is calibration:

Confusing the two is the real mistake, and it’s why “just be more confident” almost never works: it asks you to switch off both.

Why it targets the well-prepared

Three mechanisms, all described in the psychological literature well before 1978.

Reversed attribution. In the standard account of attributions, the common tendency is to credit successes to yourself and failures to circumstances. The impostor pattern is the reverse: success goes to chance, to help received, to a lenient panel; failure goes to personal inadequacy. With that accounting, no result can ever count as evidence. It’s why the feeling gets worse as results accumulate.

Comparing against the wrong denominator. Competent people know the field, so they also know the outstanding people in the field, and compare themselves to them. Incompetent people don’t know those people exist. Competence widens the view of what you still don’t know: the more you learn, the more you see what’s missing.

The environmental signal. The experience is reported more often by people who are numerically underrepresented in their setting. That’s the point pressed by Ruchika Tulshyan and Jodi-Ann Burey in Harvard Business Review (2021): treating a predictable reaction to an environment that constantly signals otherness as an individual pathology puts the cost of the correction on the wrong person. It’s an argument, not a study. But it’s a good argument.

What to actually do

1. Keep a record of facts, not feelings. One line per result: what you did, what problem it solved, what changed. It’s needed because memory is selective and stores mistakes better than successes. It’s also exactly the material two very concrete conversations require: asking for a raise and answering interview questions.

2. Reverse the attribution, in writing. When something goes well, force yourself to write one line about your contribution. When it goes badly, force yourself to write one line about external factors. This isn’t positive thinking: it’s correcting a ledger that’s systematically tilted one way.

3. Define the level the role requires. “Am I good enough?” has no answer until you specify good enough for what. A mid-level role doesn’t require being the best in the industry: it requires a finite, writable list of things. Write it, and assess yourself against that.

4. Tell one person. The strongest effect reported by people who get past it is discovering that the people they admire feel the same. Silence is what makes the pattern plausible.

5. Close a real gap, if there is one. Sometimes the doubt is information: a skill really is missing. In that case the answer isn’t psychological but practical, and time-boxed: learning a skill in 30 days.

6. Consider that the problem might be the place. If the sense of not belonging is concentrated in one specific setting and disappears elsewhere, the variable may not be you. The way to think it through without impulsive decisions is in changing jobs: the practical guide.

My take: sometimes the feeling is right

My impression is that the popularity of the phrase “impostor syndrome” has had a side effect: it’s become a convenient explanation for any professional discomfort, including the legitimate kind. Sometimes feeling not good enough isn’t a cognitive distortion but an accurate assessment of a real gap. In that case the right answer is to study, not to reframe your thoughts.

The second, less diplomatic point: I think “fake it till you make it” is harmful advice for people with this pattern. Telling someone already convinced they’re performing a role to perform it better confirms exactly the wrong premise. The alternative I’d use is declarative: “this part I know, this other part I’m learning”. It’s true, sustainable, and quite likely produces more credibility than displayed confidence.

Frequently asked questions

Is it an illness? No. It isn’t a clinical diagnosis and doesn’t appear in the diagnostic manuals. It’s an experience described in the psychological literature, with its own measurement instruments but no nosological status. If the distress is intense or persistent, that doesn’t make it less serious: it makes it a matter for a professional.

Will it go away with more experience? Not automatically. Experience can make it worse, because it raises both expectations and awareness of what you don’t know. What changes things is the criterion you judge yourself by, not the quantity of results accumulated.

How do I tell it apart from simply being incompetent? With external data: the feedback you receive, measurable results, the fact that important things get entrusted to you. If the external evidence is positive and the internal perception is negative, that mismatch is the phenomenon. If both are negative, it’s a skills gap, solvable but with different tools.

Should I tell my manager? You don’t need to name it. It’s more useful to ask for something concrete: explicit feedback on the expectations of the role. It reduces ambiguity, which is the ground the pattern grows on.

Is therapy necessary? If it interferes with sleep, relationships or the ability to work, yes, and there’s nothing disproportionate about it. The available reviews note that studies on specific treatments are scarce: all the more reason to see a professional rather than follow a protocol found online.

Sources

Founder of UpSkillLab, with a Master's in Digital Marketing from the University of Florence. Every article starts from public sources cited in the text and is drafted with the help of AI tools, under my review and editorial responsibility: no purchased content, nothing published without human checking. Read the editorial method or report an error.


Share this post:

See all articles in Career & Work

Previous Post
How to Write Effective AI Prompts (a Beginner's Guide)
Next Post
Remote Work: How to Work From Home Without Losing Productivity