Skip to content
Go back

Digital Skills: The 5% Who Can Solve Problems, and the Native Myth

Illustration of basic digital skills icons

The phrase “digital natives” was coined by Marc Prensky in a 2001 non-academic article, with no supporting data. It was hugely successful: it shaped school curricula, corporate training strategies and the widespread belief that anyone who grew up with a smartphone acquired digital competence by osmosis.

When people went and measured it, the picture came out differently. And the most useful number comes from the OECD’s international survey of adult skills.

The PIAAC finding

The OECD’s PIAAC programme measures, among other things, the ability to solve problems in technology-rich environments: using multiple applications together, filtering information, completing a multi-step task with digital tools.

Aggregate results across participating countries:

“Being able to use a phone” and “being able to solve a problem with digital tools” are two abilities the data shows to be largely uncorrelated. The first is widespread, the second isn’t.

In Europe, the Eurostat digital skills indicator puts the share of EU adults with at least basic digital skills at around half. That is why the 80% target for 2030 set by the European Digital Decade programme is considered ambitious.

The native myth, dismantled by research

Prensky’s idea was tested, and it didn’t hold.

Bennett, Maton and Kervin (British Journal of Educational Technology, 2008) carried out a critical review of the evidence, concluding that the digital natives debate had the features of an academic moral panic: strong claims, weak evidence, and far more variation within generations than between them.

Kirschner and De Bruyckere (Teaching and Teacher Education, 2017) were more direct in the title itself, The Myths of the Digital Native and the Multitasker, and linked the two beliefs: young people neither have innate digital competence nor can perform multiple cognitive tasks simultaneously without cost.

On the second point the experimental evidence is clear. Ophir, Nass and Wagner (PNAS, 2009) compared people reporting heavy media multitasking with light multitaskers: the heavy group performed worse at filtering irrelevant information and at switching between tasks.

The skill that matters more than the rest

If you had to pick one, the research points to a specific candidate, and it isn’t a piece of software.

Sam Wineburg’s group at the Stanford History Education Group (2016) collected over 7,800 student responses on tasks evaluating online information. The authors themselves called the result “bleak”: a very large share could not distinguish sponsored content from an article, nor assess source reliability.

The follow-up is the useful part. Wineburg and McGrew (Teachers College Record, 2019) compared three groups (professional historians, Stanford undergraduates and professional fact-checkers) on website evaluation tasks. The fact-checkers were markedly more accurate and faster, and they used a different strategy:

SkillHow it’s usually taughtWhat the data says
Evaluating a sourceAnalyse the page (design, URL, “about”)Leave the page and verify elsewhere
Searching for informationType the questionFrame the query around the actor, not the topic
MultitaskingPresented as an abilityAssociated with worse filtering performance
Tool useCourses per applicationMeasured returns are on skills, not software

What the European framework says, and what it doesn’t

The institutional reference for defining digital competence is DigComp, developed by the European Commission’s Joint Research Centre. Version 2.2 (Vuorikari, Kluzer, Punie, 2022) sets out five areas across eight proficiency levels: information and data literacy, communication and collaboration, content creation, safety, problem solving.

It is worth being precise about what it is: a reference framework, a shared vocabulary for describing and certifying competence. It is not an impact study and contains no estimates of how much each area is worth in earnings.

Estimates of economic returns do exist, and come from elsewhere: Falck, Heimisch-Roecker and Wiederhold (Labour Economics, 2021) used PIAAC data to isolate the wage return to ICT skills, finding a positive and significant effect once other cognitive abilities are controlled for.

The abilities worth investing in

1. Learn lateral reading today. Faced with an unfamiliar source, don’t analyse the page: open a new tab and search for the organisation’s or author’s name. It is the strategy separating fact-checkers from history professors, and it is a habit, not a course.

2. Stop measuring skills in software. The measured returns concern abilities such as solving problems, evaluating information and automating, not knowledge of an interface that changes every two years.

3. Run the honest multitasking test. For a week, close everything but one application during tasks that require thinking. If you notice a difference, that difference is the cost you were paying without accounting for it.

4. Cover the two areas with the best cost-to-benefit ratio. The data on office tasks points to spreadsheets and security hygiene as the two most transferable levers: we covered them in essential Excel functions and cybersecurity basics.

5. Use AI as a research tool, not as a source. The assistant accelerates formulation, not verification. The operating rules are in how to use ChatGPT at work and writing effective prompts.

6. Check against actual demand. Surveys of the most in-demand skills are the filter to apply before choosing what to learn.

My take: “digital native” became an excuse for adults

I think the biggest damage done by the phrase “digital native” isn’t to young people but to adults: it handed out a generational excuse (“I’m from a different era”) for a problem the PIAAC data shows is distributed across all age groups.

What strikes me as most underrated is that the digital skill with the highest return requires no software: lateral reading can be learned in an afternoon and changes how you assess any information. I haven’t measured this hierarchy, so I label it for what it is: my reading of the priorities, not a result of the studies.

Frequently asked questions

What are basic digital skills? The European reference is DigComp, which organises them into five areas: information and data, communication, content creation, safety, problem solving. It is a taxonomy, not a ranking of importance.

Are young people really better with technology? They are more exposed, which is different. Critical reviews of the digital native concept find more variation within generations than between them, and source-evaluation tests produce low scores among the youngest too.

Can digital multitasking be trained? The available data points the other way: people who report doing more of it perform worse at filtering irrelevant information. The supported strategy is reducing simultaneous sources, not training to handle them.

Do I need a digital skills certification? It depends on context: some public-sector selections require it explicitly, elsewhere it counts for little. The general rule on certifications applies here too: check whether it appears in real job ads.

Where do I start from zero? With source evaluation and a spreadsheet. They are the two areas with the broadest application and the shortest learning curve relative to the benefit.

Sources

Founder of UpSkillLab, with a Master's in Digital Marketing from the University of Florence. Every article starts from public sources cited in the text and is drafted with the help of AI tools, under my review and editorial responsibility: no purchased content, nothing published without human checking. Read the editorial method or report an error.


Share this post:

See all articles in Industries & Trends

Previous Post
How to Stop Procrastinating: What the Data Says (It Isn't Perfectionism)
Next Post
Freelancing: You Earn Less Than as an Employee, and Do It Anyway