Short-term rentals are almost always described as passive income: list the place online and collect the money. The data tell a different story. The same apartment, in the same neighborhood, earns very different amounts depending on who manages it, and the gap comes down to skills that can be learned.
That is why the sector matters to people who own no property at all. Property manager, co-host, revenue manager for vacation rentals: these roles exist because running a rental well is a trade.
Professionals versus private hosts: the measured gap
Jun Li, Antonio Moreno and Dennis Zhang compared Airbnb listings in Chicago run by professional hosts (those with several listings) with those run by private owners. Holding property and market characteristics constant, the professionals’ listings:
- earn 16.9% more per day;
- have a 15.5% higher occupancy rate;
- are 13.6% less likely to leave the market.
The authors attribute part of the gap to pricing. Private hosts tend to keep the same rate all year and do not adjust it to demand peaks such as holidays and major conventions.
One result complicates the picture, though. Kwok and Xie (International Journal of Hospitality Management, 2019) analyzed more than 320,000 listings across 10 major US markets. Here too, hosts with several units earn more, but they do it by pricing above the neighborhood average and changing the price less often. In other words, the advantage does not come from touching the rate every day: it comes from choosing the right price and knowing when to move it.
The skills that make the difference
Pricing and revenue management
This is the skill with the best-documented impact. It means reading demand (event calendars, seasonality, day of the week), knowing your direct competitors and deciding the floor below which renting is not worth it. Dynamic pricing tools help, but setting them up well takes the same reasoning. The foundation is data analysis: if you are starting from zero, the guide to data analysis is the first step.
Reputation and reviews
On Airbnb almost everyone has high ratings. Zervas, Proserpio and Byers (Marketing Letters, 2021) found that about 95% of listings have an average of 4.5 or 5 stars. The practical consequence is that a 4.6 is not a good score: in a market where the average is this high, every review below five stars counts. Responding well, preventing problems and managing expectations before arrival is communication work, not interior design.
Operations
Cleaning, linen, maintenance, check-in, emergencies. Anyone managing several units spends most of their time here: reliable suppliers, written procedures, tight turnarounds between guests. Many repetitive tasks (messages, calendars, alerts to cleaners) can be automated even if you cannot code, as explained in the guide to no-code automation.
Languages and communication
A large share of guests come from abroad. Clear, polite written English is needed every day: the listing, the instructions, the replies to reviews. Here is a method to improve your English for work.
Regulation
This is the skill private hosts underestimate most, and the one that costs the most when it is missing. Italian rules have changed a lot in three years.
The Italian rules to know in 2026
What counts as a short-term rental. It is a lease of a residential property lasting no more than 30 days, signed by private individuals outside a business activity (art. 4 of Decree-Law 50/2017).
The CIN. Every short-term or tourist rental must have a national identification code (Codice identificativo nazionale), issued by the Ministry of Tourism through the national accommodation database (BDSR). The code must be displayed outside the building and shown in every listing. Penalties are set by art. 13-ter of Decree-Law 145/2023:
| Violation | Penalty |
|---|---|
| Renting without a CIN | €800 to €8,000 |
| CIN not displayed or missing from the listing | €500 to €5,000 |
| No gas and carbon monoxide detectors or extinguishers | €600 to €6,000 |
Safety. The same article requires every rental, including those run by private owners, to have working detectors for combustible gas and carbon monoxide and portable extinguishers that meet legal standards: visible and accessible, near entrances and the highest-risk areas, at least one every 200 square meters of floor space.
Flat tax (cedolare secca). The rate is 21% for a single property, chosen in the tax return, and 26% for the others (2024 budget law).
The two-apartment threshold. From 2026 the budget law (Law 199/2025, art. 1, paragraph 17) lowered the threshold from four to two: anyone renting out three or more apartments short-term in the same year is by law running a business. That means a VAT number, business income and no flat tax. For anyone who wants to make short-term rentals a job, this is the key point: beyond two units it is a business, and it has to be planned as one.
The EU rules. Since 20 May 2026, Regulation (EU) 2024/1028 applies. It requires platforms to send authorities data on short-term rentals: nights, guests, the unit’s identifier. In Italy the required registration number is the CIN. The regulation does not replace municipal and regional rules, which can add further obligations.
Tax and local rules change often and depend on the individual case: before starting a business it is always worth talking to an accountant.
The sector has an impact, and you should know it
Anyone working in short-term rentals will be asked what effect they have on cities. The most solid research gives a precise answer. Barron, Kung and Proserpio (Marketing Science, 2021), using data from across the United States, estimate that a 1% increase in Airbnb listings raises rents by 0.018% and house prices by 0.026%. The effects are small per listing, but added up in neighborhoods where the phenomenon grows quickly they become significant. Zervas, Proserpio and Byers (Journal of Marketing Research, 2017) estimated instead that in Austin Airbnb cut hotel revenue by 8-10%, mostly for budget hotels.
Knowing these numbers lets you discuss the topic with municipalities, condominiums and clients without slogans.
Where to start
1. Practice on a single unit. The first goal is to learn the trade: pricing, reviews, procedures. One unit is enough to make mistakes at a limited cost.
2. Keep a numbers sheet. Nights sold, average rate, cleaning costs and commissions. Without these figures you do not know whether you are earning or just collecting.
3. Consider co-hosting. Managing another owner’s property for a percentage is the way to grow without buying real estate. For tax purposes it is a service activity, so the rules are those of self-employment.
4. Study the rules before you grow. Going from two to three units changes the regime. It has to be decided beforehand, not discovered afterwards.
My take: the trade is in the management, not the property
My reading is that the sector is moving from passive income to a trade. Stricter rules and the two-apartment threshold push out those who improvise, and the measured gap between professionals and private hosts says the room left belongs to those who can manage prices, guests and procedures. The skills are largely transferable: revenue management, review management and operations are the same ones hotels, agencies and vacation rental businesses look for. It is a hypothesis, not a finding, but it is why I write about this on a blog about skills rather than one about investing.
Frequently asked questions
Do you need a VAT number for short-term rentals in Italy? Up to two apartments, no, unless the activity is organized as a business. From the third apartment rented short-term, starting in 2026, the activity is presumed to be a business.
Does a single room need a CIN? Yes. The obligation covers residential units and parts of them, so a single room rented for short stays is included.
How much tax do you pay with the flat tax? 21% for the property chosen in the tax return and 26% for the other, within the two-apartment limit.
Is dynamic pricing always worth it? Not on its own. Kwok and Xie’s data show that hosts with several units earn more by positioning the price well, not by changing it constantly.
What jobs exist in the sector besides being the owner? Property manager, co-host, revenue manager, guest services and operations staff, compliance consultants. These roles require the same skills described above.
Sources
- J. Li, A. Moreno, D. J. Zhang, Pros vs Joes: Agent Pricing Behavior in the Sharing Economy, Ross School of Business Working Paper, 2016. In Chicago, professionally managed listings earn 16.9% more per day, have 15.5% higher occupancy and are 13.6% less likely to leave the market.
- L. Kwok, K. L. Xie, Pricing strategies on Airbnb: Are multi-unit hosts revenue pros?, International Journal of Hospitality Management, 2019. 320,243 listings in 10 US markets: multi-unit hosts earn more with prices above the neighborhood average and fewer changes.
- G. Zervas, D. Proserpio, J. W. Byers, A first look at online reputation on Airbnb, where every stay is above average, Marketing Letters, 2021. About 95% of listings average 4.5 or 5 stars.
- K. Barron, E. Kung, D. Proserpio, The Effect of Home-Sharing on House Prices and Rents: Evidence from Airbnb, Marketing Science, 2021. A 1% increase in listings leads to rents +0.018% and house prices +0.026%.
- G. Zervas, D. Proserpio, J. W. Byers, The Rise of the Sharing Economy: Estimating the Impact of Airbnb on the Hotel Industry, Journal of Marketing Research, 2017. In Austin, an estimated 8-10% impact on hotel revenue, concentrated on budget hotels.
- Decree-Law 18 October 2023, no. 145, art. 13-ter, Normattiva (in Italian). CIN, safety requirements and penalties.
- Decree-Law 24 April 2017, no. 50, art. 4, Normattiva (in Italian). Definition of a short-term rental (up to 30 days).
- Law 30 December 2023, no. 213, Normattiva (in Italian). 2024 budget law: flat tax at 26% beyond the first property (art. 1, paragraph 63).
- Law 30 December 2025, no. 199, Normattiva (in Italian). 2026 budget law: threshold lowered to two apartments (art. 1, paragraph 17, amending paragraph 595 of Law 178/2020).
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1028, EUR-Lex. Data collection and sharing on short-term accommodation rentals, applicable from 20 May 2026.
- Italian Ministry of Tourism, national accommodation database (BDSR). Applying for and looking up the CIN.



